Skip to content

Old vs new tax regime: how payroll teams should run TDS

How employers deduct TDS on salary under the old and new regimes: regime choice, slabs, rebate, declarations and proofs, quarterly returns and Form 16.

Saralix Team5 min read
On this page

Every April, payroll teams get the same question from employees: “Which regime should I choose?” The honest answer is that it depends on the employee, and the employer’s job is not to advise but to make the choice easy to record, deduct tax accurately and file correctly. This post explains what payroll teams need to handle for TDS on salary under both regimes.

The slabs below are the ones announced for FY 2025-26 and used in payroll. The Income-tax Act, 2025 replaces the 1961 Act from 1 April 2026 and renumbers sections, so confirm the rates, rebate and deduction limits for the current year before you configure anything.

Your obligation as an employer

When you pay salary, you must deduct tax at source based on the employee’s estimated total income for the year. This is the old section 192 duty, now carried over under the new Act. Your method is to estimate annual taxable income, compute the tax for the chosen regime, add cess, and deduct it in roughly equal monthly amounts for the remaining months.

The key word is estimate. If the estimate is wrong in April, the error compounds across twelve deductions and shows up as a large catch-up in February or March. Re-estimate whenever pay changes.

The two regimes at a glance

New regime (default). Lower slab rates and almost no deductions. As announced for FY 2025-26:

Income slab Rate
Up to Rs 4,00,000 Nil
Rs 4,00,001 to 8,00,000 5%
Rs 8,00,001 to 12,00,000 10%
Rs 12,00,001 to 16,00,000 15%
Rs 16,00,001 to 20,00,000 20%
Rs 20,00,001 to 24,00,000 25%
Above Rs 24,00,000 30%

A standard deduction of Rs 75,000 is available to salaried employees, and the section 87A rebate effectively makes tax nil for taxable income up to Rs 12,00,000, with marginal relief just above it.

Old regime. Higher slab rates, but employees can claim exemptions and deductions:

Income slab Rate
Up to Rs 2,50,000 Nil
Rs 2,50,001 to 5,00,000 5%
Rs 5,00,001 to 10,00,000 20%
Above Rs 10,00,000 30%

Standard deduction is Rs 50,000, and the rebate applies to taxable income up to Rs 5,00,000. Typical claims are HRA exemption, deductions under 80C (up to Rs 1,50,000, which includes the employee’s own PF), 80D for health insurance, 80CCD(1B) for additional NPS (Rs 50,000), home loan interest on a self-occupied property (up to Rs 2,00,000) and a handful of others.

Both regimes add surcharge for high incomes and a 4% health and education cess on the tax.

Which one is better

There is no universal answer. As a rough rule, employees with large HRA, home loan interest and 80C investments may still save under the old regime, while those without many deductions usually come out ahead under the new one. The break-even depends on total deductions relative to income, so the best tool is a side-by-side comparison with the employee’s own numbers. Employers should offer that comparison, not a recommendation.

The process, month by month

At the start of the year

  1. Default everyone to the new regime unless an employee has opted for the old one.
  2. Collect the choice. Employees opt for the old regime by informing the employer, and can change their choice each year. Set a deadline and tell people early.
  3. Collect declarations. Old-regime employees declare expected investments, rent and loan interest. Employees under the new regime mostly have nothing to declare.

During the year

  1. Deduct on the projected income. Use year-to-date actuals plus the current salary structure for the remaining months, and include one-time pay such as bonuses and arrears when they are paid.
  2. Re-run the projection after any revision, joiner, exit, bonus or regime change.
  3. Deposit TDS by the 7th of the following month (30 April for March deductions).

Late in the year

  1. Collect proofs for declared investments, rent receipts and loan certificates. Review them, and recompute tax on proven amounts rather than declared ones. Deductions that are declared but not proven are disallowed in the final months.
  2. Final true-up in the last payroll so annual tax deducted equals annual tax payable.

Quarterly returns and Form 16

TDS on salary is reported on Form 24Q each quarter. The usual due dates are 31 July, 31 October, 31 January and 31 May for the fourth quarter. Late filing attracts a daily fee, and errors lead to notices to both you and your employees.

After the final quarter, issue Form 16 by 15 June. Part A summarises the tax deducted and deposited, and Part B shows the computation. Employees use it to file their own returns, so mistakes here create work for everyone.

Common errors to avoid

  • Using the wrong regime for an employee who submitted a change mid-year without updating payroll.
  • Ignoring previous-employer income for mid-year joiners. Collect Form 16 from the previous employer, or the annual estimate will be too low.
  • Taking declarations at face value without a proof review.
  • Deducting HRA exemption without checking rent receipts and PAN of landlords where required.
  • Forgetting that the rebate under section 87A is not available against special-rate income such as certain capital gains.
  • Letting TDS collected sit undeposited past the due date.

What to ask your software

Whichever tool you use, check that it can: project annual income from actuals and the current structure; apply both regimes with rebate, marginal relief, surcharge and cess; compare regimes for an employee; track declarations and proofs; produce the 24Q data and Form 16; and show you an audit trail when someone’s regime changes.

Saralix does this: TDS is projected under the new or old regime, the 87A rebate with marginal relief, surcharge and 4% cess are applied, and the remaining tax is spread over the remaining months. Employees can compare regimes live, declare investments and upload proofs, and HR verifies and locks them. You should still sanity check a few payslips every year against the current Finance Act.

Summary

Make the regime choice simple to record, deduct on a realistic projection, review proofs before year-end, and file 24Q and Form 16 on time. Do those four things and TDS stops being the stressful part of March.

Free up to 10 employees

Run your first payroll free.

Attendance, leave, payroll and PF, ESI, PT and TDS compliance in one place. See the plans, or ask for a walkthrough.