Saralix or a payroll spreadsheet?
A spreadsheet is free, familiar and flexible. Payroll software adds statutory rules, approvals and records. Here is where each one fits.
- A spreadsheet is a fair choice for a very small team with simple pay, one person who owns it and a CA who checks the filings.
- It gets harder as you add people, branches, attendance inputs, loans and changing statutory rules, because every rule is a formula you maintain.
- Saralix replaces the formulas with built-in calculations, approval steps and an audit log, and is free up to 10 employees.
- If your payroll is stable, small and well controlled, you may not need to switch yet.
Cost and setup
| Saralix | Spreadsheets | |
|---|---|---|
| Software price | Free up to 10 employees with 1 admin. Business Rs 99 per employee per month for 11 to 100 employees, applying to all employees once above 10, plus GST. Enterprise above 100 is custom. | Usually free or already included in an office suite. The real cost is the time spent building, checking and maintaining it. |
| Trial | No trial. The Free plan is free forever up to 10 employees. | Not applicable. |
| Setup effort | Guided setup wizard, then employees fill in their own details. Existing employees can be imported from CSV with a dry run first. | You design the layout, salary components and formulas yourself, or reuse an old file. |
Payroll and compliance
| Saralix | Spreadsheets | |
|---|---|---|
| PF, ESI and TDS calculations | Built in: PF on capped or full basic, ESI up to Rs 21,000 gross, and monthly TDS projected from the year to date under the new or old regime. | You write and update each formula. Rates and ceilings change, and each change has to be found and applied by hand. |
| Professional Tax and LWF | PT tables for Gujarat, Maharashtra, Karnataka, West Bengal, Telangana, Andhra Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh, plus states with no PT. LWF for Gujarat and Maharashtra. Other states show a warning on the payslip. | Any state you build a table for. No warnings unless you add them. |
| Return and payment files | EPFO ECR 2.0 text file, ESI columns, PT summary, employee-wise TDS and a 24Q deductee annexure CSV. | Built manually or copied into the portals' formats. |
| Payslips | PDF payslips per employee, a ZIP for the month, and email to each employee. Locked data does not change afterwards. | A template you fill or mail-merge, with no lock on past months unless you add one. |
Attendance, leave and controls
| Saralix | Spreadsheets | |
|---|---|---|
| Attendance and leave inputs | Web and mobile punch, biometric push, shifts, rosters, leave policies and balances, with loss of pay carried into the run. | Typed in or pasted from other files, then reconciled by hand. |
| Approvals | Maker-checker on payroll and payments, plus approval chains for leave and corrections. | By convention. A person can change a number after someone has reviewed it. |
| Audit trail | Changes to records, approvals, exports and views of full bank account numbers are logged. | Version history if your tool provides it. It will not know which change was approved. |
| Bank files | HDFC ENet, ICICI CIB, generic CSV or your own layout, with a duplicate payment guard and reconciliation from the bank status file. | Build the upload file yourself. Duplicates and wrong columns depend on your checks. |
Saralix prices are final as published on our pricing page; GST is extra. Spreadsheet cost depends on the tool you use, which we have not researched. Check your own licence.
When a spreadsheet is fine
- You have a handful of employees, a stable salary structure and few changes month to month.
- One careful person runs payroll and a CA or consultant reviews the statutory side.
- You do not need employee self-service, approvals or an audit trail.
- You operate in one state and are comfortable updating rates when they change.
When to move to Saralix
- Attendance, leave, loans and claims all change what each person is paid.
- You want someone other than the preparer to approve payroll, with a record.
- You operate in more than one state, or you want a warning when a state is not supported.
- Employees keep asking for payslips, balances and tax documents.
Moving from a spreadsheet
- 01
Clean your employee sheet
Fix duplicate names, missing PAN and bank details, and consistent dates before importing. Saralix can import employees from CSV and shows a dry run first.
- 02
Recreate your salary structure
Set a standard template or named templates, then add your own allowances. Salary revisions are effective-dated.
- 03
Run a parallel month
Run payroll in Saralix and in your sheet for one month, then compare the register line by line before you switch.
- 04
Check statutory settings
Have your CA confirm tax slabs, state tables and the CTC definition before the first real run. See our migration post at /posts/spreadsheet-to-hrms-migration-plan/ for a plan.
Questions
Can I keep my spreadsheet for some reports?
Yes. Saralix exports reports as CSV or Excel, so you can keep using a sheet for analysis while payroll runs in the product.
Will my past months be imported?
Saralix imports employees from CSV. Past payroll history is not described as an import feature, so keep your old files for records and talk to us if you need year-to-date opening figures.
Is a spreadsheet allowed for statutory records?
That depends on the record and your auditor. Ask your CA, because requirements and formats change.
What does moving cost?
Nothing up to 10 employees. Above that it is Rs 99 per employee per month plus GST, for example Rs 2,475 a month plus GST for 25 employees.
Spreadsheet descriptions are general and not about any one product. Figures reflect Saralix information as of November 2026. Trademarks belong to their owners.
Try it with your own data.
Free for up to 10 employees. Business is Rs 99 per employee per month up to 100.